• 목록
• 답변
• 글쓰기
• 게시판 리스트 옵션
  • 수정
  • 삭제

Midway by way of ''Merchants of Immortality,'' Stephen S. Hall takes us inside a laboratory in central Massachusetts. Like the rest of the guide, the fascinating episode is intensely researched, and it's the simple, mundane details that make it work. We're given the tiny cow eggs harvested in Iowa from the ovaries of slaughtered cattle, the small white plastic tubes the a whole lot of eggs were plopped into, the thermoslike container that stored the tubes heat within the in a single day mail to Worcester. The container arrived at a drab brick laboratory constructing, the place a technician drew out the eggs, put them beneath a high-powered microscope and, using a particularly nice needle, sucked the cow DNA out of them. Taking one of those emptied eggs, one other technician caught it with a needle loaded with a human's cells. And then, ''with a barely perceptible squeeze of one hand, she deposited a single grownup pores and skin cell, with its distinctive payload of human DNA, into the egg of a creature that moos.'' With this, we turn into witnesses to one among historical past's earliest human cloning experiments. The hybrid eggs have been given a 15-microsecond, 120-volt electric zap, effectively fusing the 2 cells into one. The cells were made to start replicating in an incubator. And with sufficient replications, some of these fused cells went on to type what gave the impression to be a really human embryo. Making an embryo was as much because the scientists believed they might achieve and so far as they wished to go, Hall tells us. With such an embryo in hand, their actual aim was to harvest stem cells from it. As a surprising quantity of people appear to know nowadays, embryonic stem cells are able to forming almost any tissue in the human physique from scratch -- muscle, bone, blood vessels, even brain. Just the information that such cells exist poses the heady risk of rejuvenation, of utilizing them to develop an countless provide of spare parts -- cardiac tissue for heart assault patients, brain cells for victims of strokes or Parkinson's disease, pancreatic tissue for diabetics. This ultimate scientific quest -- this assault on the ravages of aging, doubtlessly on mortality itself, and the lengths to which we are now taking it -- is what brings Hall here. The full tale spills out in a daunting number of instructions. There is the biology of ''longevity genes,'' telomeres, stem cells and even African clawed toads to explain. There are battles between laboratories, questions of the morality of the work and collisions with national politics. There is historical past and economics. And there are the individual individuals involved to inform about, too. It is a measure of Hall's skill as a science author -- that is his fourth ebook and he has typically written for The new York Times -- that he manages to navigate through all this as lucidly as he does. The ebook isn't profitable in everything it tries to do. Hall may be virtually too evenhanded. He has a reporter's instinctive reticence about giving us his personal considering, and the guide works best when he isn't pulling punches. But he makes the biology clear with out stooping to condescension. He is admirably thorough. And he doesn't sacrifice vividness, understanding or the voices of the various key gamers. Its title however, this guide is not really about anyone chasing the elixir of immortality. Hall himself shies away from the word inside the primary 50 pages. And that is correctly -- even essentially the most fanatic researchers declare nothing like the possibility of discovering such a potion. The scientists Hall follows are after what he prefers to name ''life-extension know-how.'' Even that is an inapt time period: most drugs is a type of life-extension know-how. And the threads connecting cloning, stem cells and longevity are fairly slender. But these are the revolutionary fields in medical analysis. All of them have genuine, radical promise -- like vaccines and transplants and open-coronary heart surgical procedure not so long ago. One can see why Hall is concerned about them. So then, how are these new sciences unfolding? Hall's answer is: messily. Partly, that's how all science tales go -- they are filled with failure, weird findings, unexpected success and egos. (The opening chapter is a small gem of an instance, trailing the mercurial Leonard Hayflick, who discovered forty years in the past that human cells do not replicate indefinitely however as an alternative simply stop after a while and die.) Partially, nonetheless, the messiness is due to one thing that makes Hall's book loads darker and less heroic than the usual science story -- the brand new and now constant consciousness in the sphere of money to be made. (Hence the ''merchants'' of the title.) Just the truth that the cow-human experiment did not happen in a publicly funded laboratory but as a substitute at a personal firm -- in this case one called Advanced Cell Technology and led by Michael West, a maverick entrepreneur and notorious provocateur -- has fundamental implications. Divorced from the traditions of academic primary analysis, the place the emphasis is on open information and profit just isn't the priority, requirements begin to slide. As Hall notes, ''ACT's scientists have not published a single phrase in regards to the cow-human experiments in the scientific literature,'' the place they may very well be independently reviewed, ''although they have spoken exhaustively about them in the popular press.'' In a number of situations, https://stemcellscosts.com/ he found more information on analysis work from patent filings than from scientific publications. He saw ethics controls weaken and companies dominating the general public debate. This increasingly is the norm. Nearly all basic research in these necessary fields has moved out into the personal sector, largely, Hall exhibits, due to politics. He devotes a significant a part of the e book to peeling back the messy, contradictory, usually incoherent debates and policies. The Clinton administration proved simply unable to design a viable policy on stem cell or cloning research within the aftermath of the Lewinsky scandal. The Bush administration comes off even worse. Hall takes us via President Bush's months of indecision about what position to take on stem cell research and then their unusual culmination: on Aug. 9, 2001, in a televised speech ''which can have come as close as any presidential tackle to a national lesson in sex training,'' Bush announced that federal funding for human embryo stem cell analysis could be banned aside from work on ''present cell traces.'' There were, he said, ''more than 60'' of them. But inside days it grew to become obvious that this was not the case. In the subsequent yr, researchers found at most 4 usable cell strains. And what embryonic stem cells exist become mostly commercially owned. Academic research ground to a halt, and overnight a handful of corporations struggling to remain afloat in right this moment's uncertain financial system were given practically complete management over future research and the new era of remedies that could end result. Hall tells the whole story in very close. You end up hungry for common intervals with the digicam pulled back far enough to see where the tale is heading. In the end, though, the book is about our arrival in a place of large medical alternative and in addition baffling political idiocy. ''The lengthy-time period promise of stem cell therapy is every part it has been cracked up to be: the potential clinical influence is staggering, on a par with the therapeutic significance of antibiotics,'' Hall writes. ''But fixing all the biological problems is a staggering job, too, and it is a process that has been largely assigned, by politics and happenstance, to a handful of underfinanced, understaffed and scientifically overwhelmed boutique biotech companies.'' There are critical consequences to contemplate in the prospect that science might considerably lengthen the human life span. Children born immediately could be anticipated to reside to 90, and main breakthroughs might make that a hundred (or more?). Hall considers the pressure on social and environmental assets of an older inhabitants, the infinite arguments over whether a 30-cell embryo is life, the consequences of aging societies on family life, traditions and the situation of political power. But he finds many causes to believe that the enterprise should continue. And the deepest is moral responsibility. Faced with a physician's ready room stuffed with patients with Alzheimer's disease or Parkinson's illness or one in all a dozen other dehumanizing illnesses, can we morally say we will not pursue our period's most promising chance to relieve their misery? Hall reveals that we could already have carried out so.

Atul Gawande is an assistant professor of surgical procedure at Harvard Medical School and a staff writer for The brand new Yorker.